Lee's Resident Test
We must continually recognize the positive contributions of immigrants, but in order to successfully pass comprehensive reform we need to do as much as possible to create solutions that address realistic concerns from the welcoming community while providing more transparent and effective education to newcomers about what is expected of them. We need to think outside the box and implement new ideas to supplement the same old ideas that make sense but have failed on their own in the past and continue to fail to address one of the root challenges - cultural misunderstanding. We are unfortunately not going to get anywhere with successful reform this year or anytime in the future until we address this major challenge.
Successful reform needs to include a practical
test that immigrants must pass in order to become residents in the U.S. – for their
benefit and for the benefit of society. Newcomers must be taught and understand
critical laws, values, and systems that are different than what they are accustomed
to. The citizenship test focuses on U.S. history and government, which
is important, but we need a step prior to that to ensure that people have
learned practical information that impacts our safety, economy, health care,
education system and human relations. Like most U.S. born
citizens, I’d prefer that immigrants study about when they should go or not go
to the emergency room and how to recycle rather than when our Constitution was
written or how many stripes are on the flag.
We can learn from some other countries that address legal and cultural issues in their citizenship exams. For example, Canada includes language about protecting the environment, equality, ways to
participate in the community, and eliminating discrimination and injustice. Australia includes values such as equality, compassion, peacefulness and respect. France
includes questions regarding the definition of rape. Germany includes questions about gender equality.
An English speaking requirement (which is being proposed in most reform talk so far) will not be realistic to implement given the tremendous resources it would require and the time it would take some people to learn the language with barriers such as learning disabilities and child care.
The resident test on the other hand will be very brief and transparent – everyone will know exactly what they have to learn and what will be asked. Many immigrants will not make the effort to learn this critical information nor will they even understand how important this knowledge is (to no fault of their own) unless it is mandatory and realistic for them to learn. They will have a reasonable amount of knowledge to absorb, and this is the kind of essential information that sticks with people forever and has immediate impacts on society. The resident test will need to be translated into many languages, and it could easily be administered orally to people who are illiterate. Questions are open-ended to ensure that people aren’t simply guessing the correct answers. And the study guide with all of the answers is already there for people to easily access this information.
Instances of domestic violence, sexual harassment, child abuse, alcoholism, and
unnecessary hospital visits within the immigrant community will not be
eradicated, but they will diminish the more people are forced demonstrate their
comprehension of U.S.
This is not the solution but it is one of a few realistic ones that need to happen if we make the immigration system work better. If we administered this test to all of the undocumented people in our country right now, very few would be able to answer a majority of these questions. If we made it mandatory for them to answer these questions in order to receive resident status, they would quickly learn the answers and they would know those answers forever.
Here are some possible questions that could appear on the Resident Test:
- What are 3 reasons you would call 911? When should you not call 911?
- What are 3 reasons you would visit the emergency room?
- How many smoke detectors should you have in your home?
- What are 3 ways you can save energy at home?
- What is domestic violence? Is it only possible to occur between married couples?
- What is sexual harassment and where can it take place?
- What are common penalties for
drinking and driving? How many people are killed every year in the U.S. from
drinking and driving?
- What is child abuse?
- What is an example of child neglect?
- What is a typical normal body temperature?
- How can HIV/AIDS be spread?
- What information is often found in a housing lease?
- What date are taxes due every year?
- What is a “dependent” on your tax form?
- How do people establish good credit?
- When walking or riding a bike you should always stay on which side of the path unless you are passing someone?
- How much is a typical tip when going out to eat at a restaurant?
- What are consequences of throwing trash on the ground?
- What do people recycle in the
U.S.
and why do we recycle?
- What are three things you can do (or not do) to be a good neighbor?
- What are some benefits of volunteering in your community?
- What is considered to be
alcoholism in the U.S.?
What is Alcoholics Anonymous?
- What are some rights you have
as someone living in the U.S.?
- Approximately how many calories should the average person consume in a day?
- At a minimum, how many times a week and for how long should people exercise?
- If a man has non-consensual sex with his wife is it considered rape?
- Who is eligible to receive social security benefits?
- When is an employee eligible for overtime pay?
- What should a person do if they get pulled over by a law enforcement officer while driving?
- What are 3 forms of birth
control used in the U.S.?
- How does sugar consumption impact your dental health?
Wouldn't our society be better off if all immigrants and everyone living in our country could answer these questions with confidence? I'm going to do whatever I can to make it happen because it's a tangible, realistic-to-implement, important step, and I really want to see immigration reform pass this year. The same old solutions aren't going to get us anywhere.